EU Summit compromise: economy first, rule of law second?

On 21 July 2020, the European Council adopted conclusions on the recovery plan and multiannual financial framework for 2021-2027. EU leaders have agreed to a comprehensive package of €1 824.3 billion.

 

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF) is concerned that the allocation of EU funds is only vaguely conditionally tied to a Member State’s compliance with rule of law standards and commitments, including press and media freedom.

 

In the compromise agreement made on 20 July 2020, the final decision on how to regulate and oversee the allocation of funds has been postponed. Making the allocation of EU funds directly conditional on the rule of law is a unique opportunity to finally establish an effective instrument against non-compliance with fundamental rule of law principles, including press and media freedom. Otherwise this sends a bad sign, especially to leaders in countries such as Poland, Czech Republic and Hungary.

 

While the EU Commission, depending on interpretation of language, can apparently present concrete proposals that are linked to the rule of law situation in a country, this would require adoption though by a majority of the Council of the EU. As this may severely limit its effectiveness, an efficient regime of conditionality must be introduced.

 

We welcome the EU Covid-19 recovery fund, which hopefully will also be used to financially support a media sector that has suffered severely during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the lack of transparency on how exactly the money is allocated on a national level gives further cause for concern regarding potential misuse of EU-funds and opens the door for the arbitrary distribution of funds based on political motivations.

 

Ahead of the summit and their EU Council presidency, we urged Germany to prioritise effective solutions to overcoming challenges to media freedom in Europe. We called on EU Member States to adopt an ambitious Multiannual Financial Framework, which will strengthen the media sector and support independent journalism under the Creative Europe programme.

 

Dear President Michel, dear Council of the European Union, dear EU leaders: We acknowledge the difficulty of such negotiations in finding a compromise amongst 27 different national interests. But rule of law must be given priority. European solidarity must be tied to European values.

Read news by categories:

Related news

Feature

Greece: MFRR partners welcome acquittal of journalists in Novartis criminal case

The partner organisations of the MFRR today welcome the resounding exoneration of four Greek journalists and publishers who faced criminal charges and potential lengthy prison sentences linked to their media outlets’ investigative reporting.

READ MORE
Feature

Netherlands: Press freedom organisations welcome policy debate on media freedom and journalists’ safety

The partners in the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) and other undersigned press freedom organisations welcome the publication of the letter from the Dutch Government to the Parliament regarding a proposed policy approach on media freedom and safety of journalists.

READ MORE
Feature

ECPMF signs joint media freedom statement on the European Media Freedom Act

As the European Commission is finalising the draft proposal for a European Media Freedom Act, ECPMF has joined a coalition of media freedom groups to call for the EMFA to address issues around the European single market, media ownership and transparency of economic relations with the state, and how to support a vibrant, diverse and independent media sector.

READ MORE
Feature

Media freedom groups concerned by delay in investigation into leak of Emilia Șercan’s stolen photos

ECPMF joined a collection of media freedom and freedom of expression groups to express concern at delays to the investigation into the publication of Romanian journalist Emilia Șercan’s stolen photos and the alleged leak of key elements of the investigation into this offense. 

READ MORE
Mission

Czech Republic: MFRR pushes for reforms to strengthen independence of public broadcaster

Representatives from IPI and ECPMF travelled to Prague on 15 June to meet with officials from the Ministry of Culture and push for the development of reforms which strengthen the independence of the country’s public broadcaster.

READ MORE
Feature

Spain: Fine against photographer underscores urgent need for reform of Gag Law

Partners of the MFRR today express serious concern over the recent €1,000 fine issued to Pulitzer prize-winning photographer Javier Bauluz under Spain’s controversial “Gag Law”.

READ MORE