Social media law in Turkey: a new stage of penguinisation

20 August 2020

By Ayşe Düzkan, ECPMF Journalist in Residence

 

There was always censorship and restrictions on the media in Turkey but on the night of May 31, 2013 something happened that exceeded this. When people from all over the country took to the streets to protest against the government and the cutting down of trees for a construction site in Gezi Park, CNNTURK was broadcasting a documentary about penguins.

 

Since that night, penguins became the symbol of government interference in the media in Turkey and the Gezi protests. A few months later, when the pressure on the press began to intensify, a banner being carried at a protest organised by journalists had “Penguins are Only Nice in the North Pole” written on it.

 

That was when social media and especially Twitter began gaining importance for people living in Turkey. Information about what was happening was supplied through citizen reports over social media. This was a different situation from the organisation of people over social media in the Arab Spring. There were developments that occurred after Gezi that changed the structure of the media. The important channels on the mainstream media were handed over to government supporters using financial pressure. Media supporting the government was sustained financially by the municipalities. In fact, when metropolitan municipalities changed hands last year, some government-supported newspapers were forced to stop printing on paper.

 

Today, almost everyone in Turkey, including those who voted for the ruling party, follows current affairs on digital media. The incident that was the last straw was when a speech of President Erdoğan, was broadcast on YouTube and received thousands of dislikes. It was not possible to control internet users! They write everything they hear and that comes into their heads; the lives of government members, and their spending habits! Thus, the regulation restricting social media passed by Parliament amidst an economic crisis and a pandemic, places Turkey at a whole new stage of penguinisation.

 

The regulation requires social media network providers of foreign origin like Twitter, YouTube and Facebook to have at least one representative in Turkey and, what’s more important, to keep their data in Turkey. If they do not comply, a number of measures will be taken including bandwidth restriction, advertisement bans and content restrictions. This means that the monitoring of content will increase and accelerate. If content that is ordered to be removed by a court ruling is not taken down within 24 hours, the company will be required to pay damages. If the government demands it, companies will be required to submit information on anonymous accounts, which is one of the most critical points in my opinion, because many Turkish users use pseudonyms to avoid censorship. Yet, with this new regulation, it will become possible to identify the owners of anonymous accounts.

 

Additionally, it will not be possible to share news that the ruling party does not like. In Turkey, many police violence cases only came to light through social media. Similarly, many murders of women that were unsolved or unpunished were made public due to pressure from the social media and the perpetrators were put on trial and prosecuted. With the new law, these will all become impossible. When you share news of a website on the social media it may encounter a ban, in fact, many sites have been closed numerous times. For example, sendika.org is going for a record number of bans. It has been closed and reopened exactly 63 times. The issue is not limited to this; while writing this article access to Hornet, a social network for homosexuals, was banned. Before that, Grindr was banned. This is an indication that these restrictions don’t just target news but also lifestyles that are condemned by the ruling party.

 

Nevertheless, years of censorship have led opponents living in Turkey to gain serious preparedness in digital techniques. The majority knows ways to get around the restrictions including Virtual Private Networks (VPN). Young people born in the 2000s to economically powerful families called ‘Generation Z’ which, are of special interest to AKP psrty, literally came into the world with smart phones in their hands. So, they are totally in command of these techniques.

 

However many of those who follow the developments on social media and/or oppositional media are ruling party supporters, and in command of these techniques, So it is likely that they will abstain from using these channels, at least openly. It therefore means that the ruling party is in effect cutting off the channels for news from its own voters. Let us see how long the penguin holds up…

Photo: Ayşe Duzkan

Ayşe Duzkan

About the author

Ayşe Düzkan is a Turkish journalist and writer.

She is one of the founders of the magazines Feminist and Pazartesi.  Ayşe has worked in Demokrat, Pazartesi, Şamdan Plus, Sabah, Star and has written columns for Expres, Radikal, Milliyet, Pişmiş Kelle, 2000’de Yeni Gündem, Alarm, Özgür Politika, sendika.org, Özgürlükçü Demokrasi. She currently writes for artigercek.com and Yeni Yaşam. Ayşe has been a member of the board for DISK Basın-İş, a trade-union for journalists and media workers in publishing and printing. She has also volunteered for Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) Turkey.

Her books include: Çalar Saat, Erkekliğin Kitabında Yazmaz Bu, Behiç Aşçı Kitabı, 05. 17.

Read news by categories:

Related news

Press release

Report It campaign to highlight threats against journalists and media workers and encourage everyone to speak up and speak out

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF), which coordinates the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) has today launched the ‘Report It’ campaign amid increased threats to journalists and media workers across Europe. In addition to creating awareness about different threats to press and media freedom, the Report It campaign encourages everyone to speak up and speak out against violations that they witness or experience in this regard.

READ MORE
Statement

ECPMF and MFRR partners write letter to the Greek authorities voicing concern over restricted access for media workers to Moria refugee camp

The Greek authorities are undermining press freedom and threatening the public’s right to know by restricting access for media workers to sites where refugees and asylum seekers are held following the fire that destroyed the Moria camp

READ MORE
Statement

MFRR partners write letter of concern to Albanian government regarding the plan to amend the country’s audio visual laws

We are writing to express our grave concern about the apparent plans of the Parliament of Albania to ignore the issues raised in Venice Commission Opinion No. 980/2020 of 19 June 2020, further threatening press freedom and the right to freedom of expression and to information in Albania.

READ MORE
Statement

ECPMF sign joint statement issuing 5 demands for an ambitious European Democracy Action Plan

Democracies in Europe have been faced with numerous challenges over the past decade, including increasing political polarisation, closing democratic space, increased mass surveillance, popular disillusionment with representative politics and democratic institutions, and increasingly assertive authoritarian global players. There is widespread recognition of the fact that democracy is under pressure across the world.

READ MORE
Press release

Wegen wiederholter Zusammenstöße: ECPMF veröffentlicht Codex, um Verhältnis zwischen Polizei und Presse in Deutschland zu verbessern

Das Verhältnis von Polizei und Journalist:innen ist angespannt. Medienschaffende beklagen ungerechtfertigte Behinderungen ihrer Arbeit, die zu Lasten der Pressefreiheit gingen. Zugleich kritisieren Polizist:innen, dass ihre Arbeit medial verzerrt dargestellt wird. Das ECPMF und Partnerhaben ein Codex entwickelt, um einen Dialog zu starten.

READ MORE
Statement

ECPMF calls on Turkey drop the charges against journalist Oktay Candemir and return his confiscated property

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom, as part of  Media Freedom Rapid Response calls on the Turkish authorities to immediately and unconditionally drop the charges against freelance journalist Oktay Candemir and to return his confiscated property in full and without delay.

READ MORE