French draft law on dissemination of images of law enforcement officers of the national police and gendarmerie.

Press-ECPMF

11 November 2020

No Comments

France: concerns about new draft law that would make it illegal to publish images of police and gendarmes at work

French draft law on journalists and police

French draft law on dissemination of images of law enforcement officers of the national police and gendarmerie.

mfrr logo

 

 

 

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF) and European Federation of Journalists (EFJ), as part of the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR), with French unions SNJ, SNJ-CGT, CFDT-Journalistes, are concerned about a legislative proposal currently pending in the French parliament, which would make it illegal to disseminate images of law enforcement officers of the national police and gendarmerie. We call on the members of Parliament to delete the proposed text.

 

Legislative proposal No. 3452 on global security was introduced by Members of Parliament of the presidential majority on 20 October 2020. The text proposes a host of legislative changes that purport to address the “new challenges for French security” and strengthen law enforcement to this end. In article 24, the legislative proposal advances the amendment of the 1881 law on press freedom, to add a provision (new Art. 35 quinquies) that would make it punishable by one year of imprisonment and a fine of 45 000 euro to disseminate, with the intent of causing psychological or physical harm, an image of the face or any other element that could identify a law enforcement officer in the course of exercising his or her duty.

 

As is set out in the Press Freedom Police Codex based on case-law of the European Court of Human Rights, “journalists should have the right to identify individual police staff and to document and report on the work of the police forces.” As such, we reiterate the concern previously expressed by the general assembly of the European Federation of Journalists and the journalists’ union SNJ, SNJ-CGT that this provision will impede journalists and media workers from doing their job. In this regard, the provision’s inclusion of a required intent to cause harm is not a sufficient safeguard. First, it does not prevent the prosecutor from bringing cases where the intent of the journalist is unknown, leaving it to the court to decide that matter. As the case progresses, the affected journalist has to deal with the cost and stress of being the defendant in a criminal lawsuit. Second, it establishes an insignificant barrier to bring actions when police and gendarmerie officers could easily argue that they were psychologically affected by the dissemination of their image by a journalist, creating the possibility that the intent might be established in court. Overall, this lack of adequate safeguards risks creating an avenue for gag lawsuits.

 

This latest legislative proposal is one of many attempts to significantly restrict the space within which journalists can operate. In September, Gérald Darmanin, Minister of the Interior, presented the National Policing Plan intended for police and gendarmes. In particular, the document discriminates between journalists “holders of a press card and accredited to the authorities” and others, even though the exercise of the profession of journalist, as defined in the French Labour Code, does not require the possession of a press card. Further, the proposal also states that the offence consisting of remaining in a crowd after having been warned to disperse by the police does not include any exceptions for journalists.

 

Further, there have also been a number of examples of police officers themselves threatening journalists and media workers during their work. This includes, among many others, the injuring of freelance journalist Stéphanie Roy after she was hit by a grenade thrown by police officers while covering a protest in Paris for press agency Line Presse, the unwarranted arrest of journalists at two separate environmental protests at Roissy-Charles de Gaulle airport, Orly airport as well as at Annecy Meythet airport where two journalists were questioned by police for covering Extinction Rebellion actions and in 2019, the arrest of two journalism students from the Higher School of Journalism (ESJ). The school itself stated that “the evidence in our possession leads us to believe that they were arrested for taking pictures of police officers in action.” SNJ has identified almost 200 journalists prevented from exercising their profession in the last two years and numerous alerts have been posted on the Council of Europe’s Platform to promote the protection of journalism and the safety of journalists. That same year, the Independent Union of Police Commissioners (Syndicat Indépendant des Commissaires de Police – SICP) posted a message on Twitter naming five French journalists as “the main actors” in the “fight against National Police” in France. These examples illustrate an erosion of trust and demonisation of media actors that we fear will only be reinforced if this legislative proposal is adopted.

 

In light of these restrictive provisions for media freedom and this dangerous context, we call on the members of Parliament to stand up for media freedom and vote against the proposed amendment to the law of 29 July 1881.

Signed by:

Syndicat national des journalistes

Syndicat national des journalistes CGT (SNJ-CGT)

CFDT-Journalistes

European Federation of Journalists (EFJ)

European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF)

This statement is part of the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR), an Europe-wide mechanism, which tracks, monitors and responds to violations of press and media freedom in EU Member States and Candidate Countries. This project provides legal and practical support, public advocacy and information to protect journalists and media workers. The MFRR is organised by an consortium led by the European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF) with ARTICLE 19, the European Federation of Journalists (EFJ), Free Press Unlimited (FPU), the Institute for Applied Informatics at the University of Leipzig (InfAI), International Press Institute (IPI) and CCI/Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso Transeuropa (OBCT). The project is co-funded by the European Commission. www.mfrr.eu

Read news by categories:

Related news

Statement

Civil society recommendations: how the European Commission can improve the credibility, inclusiveness and impact of the Rule of Law Report

READ MORE
Statement

MFRR partners concerned about wave of abusive legal actions against Croatian outlet

Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) partners are highly concerned about the wave of abusive legal actions against Croatian online news outlet Index.hr.

READ MORE
Statement

Romania: Filmmakers badly beaten while shooting documentary on illegal logging

The undersigned partners of the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) today express serious concern over the brutal beating of two filmmakers who were shooting a documentary about illegal logging in Romania and call on the country’s prosecutor general and law enforcement authorities to ensure all those responsible are swiftly brought to justice.

READ MORE
Statement

MFRR partners welcome European Commission’s Recommendation on protection, safety and empowerment of journalists

The partner organisations in the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) welcome the European Commission’s Recommendation on ensuring the protection, safety and empowerment of journalists and media professionals in the European Union, presented today.

READ MORE
Statement

MFRR: EU action needed to tackle spyware abuses after Pegasus revelations

As the European Parliament today debates the Pegasus spyware scandal, the undersigned partners of the Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) call for an immediate investigation into the alleged use of the spyware against journalists by Hungarian authorities and urge the strong implementation of new EU rules on the export of cyber-surveillance technology around the world.

READ MORE
Statement

Urgent solution needed as Slovenian Press Agency funding crisis passes 250 days

More than 250 days have now passed since the Slovenian Press Agency (STA) last received state funding for carrying out its public service mission from the government of Janez Janša, which currently presides over the Presidency of the Council of the European Union.

READ MORE