"We will not yield to pressure"

Roberta Knoll

05 November 2020

No Comments

22 Slovene editors write joint public letter

22 Editors-in-Chief of Slovene media outlets co-signed a public letter condemning the attacks, scapegoating and intimidation directed at media outlets during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. Working with the Društvo Novinarjev Slovenije (DNS), as part of the Media Freedom Rapid Response, ECPMF has republished the letter in the original Slovene and an English translation. For more information please click here.

 

English Language version (see below for original Slovene language version)

 

We will not yield to pressure

 

As editors of major Slovenian media, we are addressing this letter to the Slovenian public because we are aware of the momentousness and the critical nature of the moment in which we find ourselves as a result of the novel coronavirus pandemic. All of us, be it doctors, healthcare staff, politicians and other decision-makers, or journalists and editors, are in the midst of the worst global health, social and economic crisis of our generation. In truth, it comes down to each and every one of us, us as a society. The fight against the virus and “victory” over what only months ago seemed like an unimaginable chapter from a history book or a sci-fi story better left on the big screen, can only be achieved as a collective effort by the entire society. This is both our joint responsibility and a trial testing our ability to make rational decisions, show solidarity, tolerance and patience, and our ability for respectful dialogue. If ever, now is the time when we have to be able to reflect upon ourselves, otherwise the consequences will be terrifying, causing irreparable damage for generations to come.

 

The media, journalists and editors, and other creators of media content are aware of our role and our responsibility in this deep and brutal crisis and continue to do our job with this awareness. We are certain that in the course of the past months, readers, listeners and viewers have been able to gain a comprehensive picture of the developments related to Covid-19 through a variety of media channels, content formats and genres. First of all, let us underline that no matter the extraordinary times we live in, the media remains accountable to the public: by asking questions, even though they may be uncomfortable for those in power, we are obligated to publish comprehensive and relevant information, put developments into broader context, and explain the context itself. To do this, we look for answers from experts and insist on corroboration in line with professional standards in the face of a stampede of false theories and dangerously oversimplified interpretations which have no scientific merit. The only thing that counts for us is the truth. We raise awareness and we educate, but at the same time we do not keep quiet about dubious actions by those in power. We are doing our job and we are confident that we have done it well and to the best of our abilities in the past months.

 

We are aware that in many ways we could not prepare completely for the situation we find ourselves in, because this situation has no parallel in modern time. We are aware that the situation demands extraordinary and often exceptionally painful measures that affect, in ways previously unimaginable, our lives and even encroach on the achievements of civilisation, the rights and freedoms of democracy. It is true that many countries around the world are taking unpleasant decisions. Slovenia is no exception in that. But it is often an exception in something we are very worried about and something we cannot accept as a part of “the new normal”: in the standard of communication with citizens, both direct or through various media and other channels, in attacks against the media and journalists, their discreditation and demonisation, in ascribing non-existing ulterior motives to them, and in pushing them into the ring of political battle. We reject this.

 

Instead of looking for scapegoats – in recent weeks the media in particular has been intensely targeted with false accusations – those in power in similar democracies than ours justify their steps, decisions and measures mostly consistently, comprehensively and with tolerance, helping people make sense of them. In few countries have governments intervened as intensively as in Slovenia in fields that have nothing to do with fighting this crisis, despite the declarative focus on this very crisis. And not only that, there are few other countries in the EU where journalists are subjected to direct lying, insinuations, manipulations and insults from those in power, starting with the top of the government, to the degree this is the case in Slovenia. We believe that these incidents have exceeded the limits of what is acceptable and do not benefit anybody, except perhaps those with very particular political interests. Such incidents are documented and all representative and relevant international organisations dealing with the protection of free and independent journalism, one of the key achievements of independent Slovenia, have been notified about them.

 

The consequences of the settling of scores with the media are destructive for society at large. Such an atmosphere hampers the functioning of institutions and individuals, and also has a significant effect on the lives of the citizens. The media have entered the crisis with a backpack full of problems from the past, including a long period of sustained non-strategic and irresponsible media ownership, outdated media legislation that does not have a comparison at EU level, and problems with funding and staffing. In this situation, the pressure from the authorities most of us face weekly, if not daily, is an additional burden that hampers good journalism. We do not shy away from criticism, not even sharp criticism, and we do not deny making mistakes.

 

The crisis has laid bare many things but even more so, it has demonstrated the undisputed fact that citizens need good journalism and, judging by surveys, are consuming it voraciously. Without high-quality media services, the knowledge and understanding of the virus among the public, and the awareness of the dangers it brings, would be significantly poorer. Neither this crisis nor anything else may be used as a pretence for attempts to impose harmful changes to the media legislation and attempts at political interference in the independence of media organisations.

 

We will not yield to pressure. We will not bend our truthful stance or our obligation to the public. The energy and time those in power are expending to discredit journalists and exert pressure on the media would be better spent managing this crisis better. This should be the objective for the government. And it is in the interest of all of us as a society.

Editors-in-chief

Matija Stepišnik, VečerNejc Jemec, Val 202, 2nd programme of Radio SlovenijaManica J. Ambrožič, Information programme of TV Slovenija | Bojan Budja, Delo, Slovenske noviceMojca Petrič Bužan, Regional TV programme, RTV centre Koper – CapodistriaTomaž Karat, Regional TV programme, RTV centre MariborSilva Križman, Primorske noviceMiran Lesjak, Dnevnik | Robert Levstek, Radio Maribor – Regional programme of Radio Slovenija | Goran Obrez, Ekipa SNGregor Peternel, Sports programme of TV Slovenija | Danijel Poslek, Prvi, 1st programme of Radio SlovenijaAndraž PöschlCulture and arts programme of TV SlovenijaDarko Pukl, Radio SiGrega Repovž, Mladina | Simon Rosc, Novice Svet24Andrej Šavko, Radio Koper – Regional programme of Radio Slovenija | Barbara Štrukelj, Slovenian Press AgencySilvester Šurla, Reporter | Tatjana Tanackovič, Nedeljski dnevnikVanja Vardjan, Entertainment programme of TV Slovenija | Matej Venier, Ars – 3rd programme of Radio Slovenija

Slovene Language version (originally published here):

 

Na slovensko javnost se kot uredniki večjih slovenskih medijev obračamo s pismom, ker se zavedamo pomembnosti in kritičnosti trenutka, v katerem smo se znašli zaradi pandemije novega koronavirusa. Smo sredi globalne zdravstvene, socialne, gospodarske krize generacije, pa naj gre za zdravnike, zdravstvene delavce, politike in druge odločevalce ali novinarje in urednike. V resnici gre za čisto vsakega od nas, za nas kot družbo. Spopad z virusom in »zmaga« nad nečim, kar se je še mesece nazaj zdelo tako rekoč nepredstavljiva lekcija iz zgodovinskih učbenikov, kot fikcija iz prihodnosti, ki naj ne uide iz znanstvenofantastičnih filmov, je lahko le kolektivna akcija družbe. Je naša skupna odgovornost in test, ki preizkuša našo sposobnost razumnih ravnanj, odločitev, solidarnosti, strpnosti, potrpežljivosti in spoštljivega dialoga. Če kdaj, se moramo biti sedaj sposobni pogovarjati in pogovoriti o sebi, sicer bodo posledice strašljive in bodo nepopravljivo prizadele generacije, ki prihajajo.

 

Mediji, novinarji in uredniki, ki v njih delamo, in drugi soustvarjalci medijskih vsebin se svoje vloge, odgovornosti z vso globino in brutalnostjo krize zavedamo in v skladu s tem opravljamo in bomo opravili naš del naloge. Prepričani smo, da so v zadnjih mesecih bralci, poslušalci in gledalci prek različnih medijskih kanalov, vsebinskih formatov in žanrov lahko dobili celovit vpogled v dogajanje, povezano s covidom-19.

 

Naj pri tem najprej poudarimo, da smo mediji ne glede na izjemnost časa, v katerem živimo, kot vedno najprej odgovorni javnosti: s postavljanjem vprašanj sogovornikom, četudi za nosilce moči neprijetnih, smo ji dolžni podati celostne, relevantne informacije, dogodke pa obenem umeščati v širši kontekst, ga pojasnjevati. Pri tem odgovore intenzivno iščemo pri stroki, v stampedu lažnih teorij in nevarno poenostavljenih interpretacij, ki nimajo nobene znanstvene osnove, vztrajamo pri preverjanju v skladu z vsemi profesionalnimi standardi poklica. Za nas šteje le resnica. Ozaveščamo in izobražujemo, obenem pa ne molčimo ob sočasnih dvomljivih ravnanjih nosilcev moči. Opravljamo torej svoje delo. Prepričani smo, da smo ga v zadnjih mesecih opravili dobro, po najboljših močeh.

 

Zavedamo se, da se v marsičem na razmere, v katerih smo, doslej nismo mogli v celoti pripraviti, gre za situacijo, ki v modernem času nima enakovredne primerjave. Zavedamo se, da so zato potrebni tudi izjemni in nemalokrat izjemno boleči ukrepi, ki posegajo v naša življenja in celo civilizacijske pridobitve, v pravice in svoboščine demokratičnih ureditev na doslej nezamisljiv način. Drži, da neprijetne odločitve sprejemajo mnoge države po vsem svetu. V tem nismo nikakršna izjema. Smo pa nemalokrat izjema v nečem, kar nas zelo skrbi in česar ne moremo sprejeti kot del »nove normalnosti«: v nivoju komuniciranja z državljani, ali neposrednem ali prek različnih medijskih in drugih kanalov, v napadih na medije, novinarje in novinarke, njihovem diskreditiranju in demoniziranju, pripisovanju ozadij, ki ne obstajajo, njihovem potiskanju v ring političnih bojev. To zavračamo.

 

Namesto iskanja krivcev, pri čemer smo pri nas v zadnjih tednih še posebno intenzivno na tapeti neresničnih obtožb ravno mediji, v primerljivih demokratičnih državah vladajoči poteze, odločitve, ukrepe večinoma konsistentno, strpno in razumljivo utemeljujejo in usklajeno osmišljajo. Redkokje oblasti tako intenzivno posegajo na področja, ki s spopadanjem s krizo nimajo nikakršne zveze, navkljub deklarativni osredotočenosti prav na spopadanje s krizo. In, ne nazadnje, redkokje v EU so novinarji tako kot v Sloveniji izpostavljeni neposrednim zavajanjem, podtikanjem, širjenju manipulacij in žalitvam predstavnikov oblasti, začenši z vrhom vlade. Seznam vseh tovrstnih incidentov – ti so po našem mnenju prebili vse meje sprejemljivega in ne koristijo nikomur, razen morda zelo partikularnim političnim interesom – je dokumentiran in o njih so bile obveščene tudi vse reprezentativne in relevantne mednarodne organizacije za zaščito svobodnega in neodvisnega novinarstva, ki je bilo ena od ključnih pridobitev slovenske osamosvojitve.

 

Posledice obračunavanja z mediji so za vse družbo uničujoče: takšno okolje otežuje delovanje institucij in posameznikov, obenem pa pomembno vpliva na življenja državljanov. Mediji smo krizo pričakali z nahrbtnikom težav iz preteklosti, dolgo časa vzdrževanega nestrateškega in neodgovornega medijskega lastništva, evropsko neprimerljive, zastarele medijske zakonodaje, finančnih in kadrovskih zagat. V takšnih razmerah pritiski oblasti, s katerimi se nas večina sooča tedensko, če že ne dnevno, pomenijo dodatno breme in otežujejo kakovostno novinarsko delo. Ne bežimo pred kritiko, tudi ostro ne, ne zanikamo, da delamo tudi napake.

 

Kriza je razkrila in razgalila marsikaj, še bolj pa je poudarila neizpodbitno dejstvo: da državljani kakovostno novinarstvo potrebujejo in sodeč po raziskavah po njem tudi intenzivno posegajo. Brez kakovostnega medijskega servisa bi bilo vedenje, razumevanje virusa in zavedanje o njegovi nevarnosti in žal nemalokrat smrtonosnosti bistveno slabše. Ne kriza ne karkoli drugega ne more biti alibi za poskuse škodljivega spreminjanja medijske zakonodaje in poskuse političnih vdorov v neodvisnost medijskih organizacij.

 

Pod pritiski ne bomo klonili. Ne bomo spreminjali resnicoljubne in javnosti zavezane drže. Celotno energijo in čas, ki ju predstavniki oblasti namenjajo diskreditaciji novinarstva in pritisku na medije, naj smotrneje usmerijo v boljše upravljanje krize. To bi moral biti cilj vlade. Je pa v interesu vseh nas kot družbe.

Odgovorni uredniki medijev:

Matija Stepišnik, Večer | Nejc Jemec, Val 202, 2. program Radia Slovenija | Manica J. Ambrožič, Informativni program TV Slovenija | Bojan Budja, Delo, Slovenske novice | Mojca Petrič Bužan, Regionalni TV program, RTV center Koper – Capodistria | Tomaž Karat, Regionalni TV program, RTV center Maribor | Silva Križman, Primorske novice | Miran Lesjak, Dnevnik | Robert Levstek, Radio Maribor – Regionalni program Radia Slovenija | Goran Obrez, Ekipa SN | Gregor Peternel, Športni program TV Slovenija | Danijel Poslek, Prvi, 1. program Radia Slovenija | Andraž Pöschl, Kulturni in umetniški program TV Slovenija | Darko Pukl, Radio Si | Grega Repovž, Mladina | Simon Rosc, Novice Svet24 | Andrej Šavko, Radio Koper – Regionalni program Radia Slovenija | Barbara Štrukelj, Slovenska tiskovna agencija | Silvester Šurla, Reporter | Tatjana Tanackovič, Nedeljski dnevnik | Vanja Vardjan, Razvedrilni program TV Slovenija | Matej Venier, Ars – 3. program Radia Slovenija

Photo: Luigi Rosa // flickr.com

Read news by categories:

Related news

Statement

Turkey: Concern over proposals to introduce new regulation of “fake” and “foreign-funded” news

The Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) and undersigned partner organisations are concerned about and condemn recent statements by Turkish President Erdoğan and other government officials pertaining to the introduction of new regulation of so-called fake news and “foreign-funded” news in the country.

READ MORE
Statement

Hungary: MFRR highly alarmed by Pegasus surveillance revelations

The Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) is highly alarmed by the revelations by a consortium led by French NGO Forbidden Stories about the surveillance of journalists, human rights defenders, lawyers and others through the Pegasus spyware program developed by Israeli company NSO Group.

READ MORE
SLAPP

UK: New policy paper on countering legal intimidation and SLAPPs

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECPMF) supports a new policy paper by the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition, titled "Countering Legal Intimidation and SLAPPs".

READ MORE
Statement

Belarus: Joint call condemning raids on media and HRDs and demanding the release of those detained

READ MORE
Statement

Georgia: ECPMF saddened by death of Alexandr Lashkarava

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom (ECMPF) is saddened by the death of Georgian TV camera operator Alexandr Lashkarava. Last week, far-right assailants severely beat him while he was covering attacks on LGBTQI+ activists in Tbilisi. A few days later, on 10 July, he was found dead at his home by his mother.

READ MORE
Statement

Albania: Concern after government ally elected to head key media regulator

The Media Freedom Rapid Response (MFRR) today expresses deep concern about the future impartiality and independence of Albania’s Audiovisual Media Authority (AMA) following the election of a close associate of the ruling Socialist Party to head the media regulator.

READ MORE